Method

Where the tape meets itself: reading the join

Which mark on a girth tape counts when the end overlaps the start, and the small reading errors that creep in at the join.

By 5 min readMethod

Guides on Method: Adding up the errors, Repeatability and agreement, start to finish, Bone-pressed length, start to finish, Stretched flaccid length, and why the clinics take it, Girth, done the way the studies do it, The measurement glossary

On a girth tape the number you read is the mark on the lower layer that sits exactly under the zero edge of the upper layer, with your eye directly above that point. That is the join, and it is where most of the small errors in a girth reading live. This post covers what to read there and how the reading drifts when you do not look straight down.

What the join is

A flexible tape goes around once and its free end passes over or under its own start. The circumference is the length of tape that actually encloses the loop, which is the distance from the zero of the tape to the point where the loop closes. At the join there are two layers of tape, and the reading is taken where one layer's edge lies across the other's scale.

Everything that matters follows from that. You are reading a mark on one layer against an edge on the other, which means two surfaces at slightly different heights and a line of sight that has to be square to both.

Which mark counts

Three situations come up.

  • The zero end lies on top. Read the mark on the lower, scale-carrying layer that the zero edge of the upper layer covers. The zero edge is the reference line.
  • The scale end lies on top. Read the number at the point where the upper layer crosses the lower layer's end edge, and be clear which edge of the lower tape you are lining up against.
  • A tape with a tab or a self-locking window. The window or pointer is the reference, and the mark shown in it is the figure. Check once that the window's reference line is the zero of the scale and not merely a marker; the construction varies.

In all three the question is the same: which edge is the reference line, and is it the same one every time? Picking an edge differently from one reading to the next is a way of generating spread out of nothing. Which edge of a tape to read in general is handled in which tape edge to read, and this note does not repeat it.

Parallax at the join

Parallax is the apparent shift of a mark when your eye is not square to the surface. At the join it is worse than on a ruler laid against an object, because the upper layer sits slightly above the lower, so the edge you read against and the mark you read are at different depths.

The effect has a direction. Look from one side and the mark appears to sit on one side of the edge; look from the other and it appears on the other. The size grows with the gap between the layers and with how oblique your view is. For a thin cloth tape the gap is small, and for a thick vinyl or a tape with a raised lock it is larger.

A few plain habits keep it down.

  1. Bring your eye directly over the join before reading, rather than reading at an angle from where you happen to be.
  2. Keep the join flat. A tape twisted at the overlap lifts one layer and raises the gap.
  3. Read the mark and the edge in one look, without moving your head between them.
  4. Use the same viewing arrangement each time, so any residual parallax is a constant rather than a variable.

The Joint Committee for Guides in Metrology's Guide to the expression of uncertainty in measurement (JCGM, 2008) lists personal bias in reading an analogue scale among the recognised sources of measurement uncertainty, and parallax is the classic form of it.

Reading to the mark

Once the edge is chosen and your eye is square, there is a second small question: what do you do when the edge falls between two marks? Do not round on the spot. Write down the nearest mark and note a half-division if you can judge one honestly, the way interpolating between ruler marks describes, then round later under the rule you set in advance.

Rounding at the join, as you read, mixes two decisions together and tends to push the number in whichever direction you were expecting.

Tension and the join

A tape that is pulled harder reads shorter on the girth because it indents what it wraps and takes up the slack at the join. That is a tension effect rather than a reading effect, and tape tension, snug not tight covers it. The two interact at the join in one specific way: when you adjust tension, the layers slide against each other, and the mark you were about to read moves. Settle the tension first, then read, and do not touch the tape once you have started reading.

Marking where the tape sits

Girth depends on where along the shaft the tape lies, and the join does not help you with that. If you want to know the tape was at the same place on every reading, marking the tape position is the relevant technique, and it is separate from reading the join.

Writing it into the method line

The join choice is cheap to record and expensive to forget. In the method line, as the convention lays out, add a few words on the reference edge and the viewing posture, for example "read at zero edge, eye square to join". Then your later readings, and anyone else comparing with them, share a definition.

Where other sites pick up

A reading taken off a tape is a different kind of number from a score someone assigns. How human judges differ from one another is a question that site covers, and how a score is built is another. Getting started with a rating service, if that is the next step, is covered at the cockrate hub, and a number from Rate Cock has no join to read, because it describes a photograph rather than a circumference.

Read next

Full archive